Comments on: “I Always Watch You from the Sky” Wrote Wendy (Part 1) http://ruleofrosemysteries.com/2008/10/27/clues/i-always-watch-you-from-the-sky-wrote-wendy/ A spoiler-intensive RoR plot-theory blog Tue, 22 May 2012 12:45:33 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.9.1 hourly 1 By: PokerNemesis http://ruleofrosemysteries.com/2008/10/27/clues/i-always-watch-you-from-the-sky-wrote-wendy/#comment-12107 PokerNemesis Tue, 10 Mar 2009 11:44:15 +0000 http://ruleofrosemysteries.com/?p=234#comment-12107 Welcome, mella! On the idea that the original Joshua might have died from a swing accident, see the comments thread of my blog-post: <a href="http://ruleofrosemysteries.com/2009/02/17/mysteries/see-all-walkthrough-with-commentary-the-gingerbread-house-chapter-part-6-mysterious-ropes/" rel="nofollow">See-all Walkthrough, with Commentary: "The Gingerbread House" Chapter (Part 6): Mysterious Ropes</a> ~ Welcome, mella!

On the idea that the original Joshua might have died from a swing accident, see the comments thread of my blog-post:
See-all Walkthrough, with Commentary: “The Gingerbread House” Chapter (Part 6): Mysterious Ropes
~

]]> By: Masq http://ruleofrosemysteries.com/2008/10/27/clues/i-always-watch-you-from-the-sky-wrote-wendy/#comment-12059 Masq Tue, 10 Mar 2009 02:32:20 +0000 http://ruleofrosemysteries.com/?p=234#comment-12059 He may have died from falling off a swing (internal injuries) or something of the like. But I think the main issue of this post isn't that he did or didn't die or that he should still be around. He may have died from falling off a swing (internal injuries) or something of the like.

But I think the main issue of this post isn’t that he did or didn’t die or that he should still be around.

]]> By: mella http://ruleofrosemysteries.com/2008/10/27/clues/i-always-watch-you-from-the-sky-wrote-wendy/#comment-12058 mella Tue, 10 Mar 2009 02:15:51 +0000 http://ruleofrosemysteries.com/?p=234#comment-12058 i would think that the real joshua got sick and died (gregory's diary.) i mean why else would he not be around? i would think that the real joshua got sick and died (gregory’s diary.)
i mean why else would he not be around?

]]> By: Aya Moto http://ruleofrosemysteries.com/2008/10/27/clues/i-always-watch-you-from-the-sky-wrote-wendy/#comment-7926 Aya Moto Wed, 29 Oct 2008 22:04:21 +0000 http://ruleofrosemysteries.com/?p=234#comment-7926 Thank you Masq for evaluating on my idea, that was my exact thought! I'm sorry I couldn't respond earlier, I was at school ^^; Glad you share the idea, and glad that you like it too, PokerNemesis! We're glad to help out anytime :D -Kara (About to read the next post!) Thank you Masq for evaluating on my idea, that was my exact thought! I’m sorry I couldn’t respond earlier, I was at school ^^; Glad you share the idea, and glad that you like it too, PokerNemesis! We’re glad to help out anytime :D

-Kara (About to read the next post!)

]]> By: iKing http://ruleofrosemysteries.com/2008/10/27/clues/i-always-watch-you-from-the-sky-wrote-wendy/#comment-7898 iKing Wed, 29 Oct 2008 00:05:03 +0000 http://ruleofrosemysteries.com/?p=234#comment-7898 hmmmm. (shrugs) i always related it to the airship hmmmm. (shrugs)

i always related it to the airship

]]> By: Cherrona http://ruleofrosemysteries.com/2008/10/27/clues/i-always-watch-you-from-the-sky-wrote-wendy/#comment-7889 Cherrona Tue, 28 Oct 2008 10:36:27 +0000 http://ruleofrosemysteries.com/?p=234#comment-7889 PokerNemesis said: <blockquote> I think the best evidence on that subject is the photo that Jennifer can find on Gregory’s desk. But, as I started writing about the photo, I came to realize that there was enough to say about it that I should save it for a blog-post. </blockquote> That proves my theory wrong then. :D lol PokerNemesis said:

I think the best evidence on that subject is the photo that Jennifer can find on Gregory’s desk. But, as I started writing about the photo, I came to realize that there was enough to say about it that I should save it for a blog-post.

That proves my theory wrong then. :D lol

]]> By: PokerNemesis http://ruleofrosemysteries.com/2008/10/27/clues/i-always-watch-you-from-the-sky-wrote-wendy/#comment-7887 PokerNemesis Tue, 28 Oct 2008 09:38:03 +0000 http://ruleofrosemysteries.com/?p=234#comment-7887 fireflys_locket asks: <blockquote>is the Rose Garden considered a part of the airship?</blockquote> I've proposed that the rickety shed might have been regarded as part of the airship. So, if that is true, in theory the rose garden could be part of the airship as well. But I can't think of any area of the airship that seems to me to be a transformation of the rose garden. fireflys_locket asks:

is the Rose Garden considered a part of the airship?

I’ve proposed that the rickety shed might have been regarded as part of the airship. So, if that is true, in theory the rose garden could be part of the airship as well.

But I can’t think of any area of the airship that seems to me to be a transformation of the rose garden.

]]> By: PokerNemesis http://ruleofrosemysteries.com/2008/10/27/clues/i-always-watch-you-from-the-sky-wrote-wendy/#comment-7885 PokerNemesis Tue, 28 Oct 2008 09:14:39 +0000 http://ruleofrosemysteries.com/?p=234#comment-7885 To Cherrona: I think the best evidence on that subject is the photo that Jennifer can find on Gregory's desk. But, as I started writing about the photo, I came to realize that there was enough to say about it that I should save it for a blog-post. I already have tomorrow's blog-post written (and I promised someone--two days ago--I'd post that in one or two days), so look for my blog-post about the photo to appear on the day after tomorrow. To Cherrona:

I think the best evidence on that subject is the photo that Jennifer can find on Gregory’s desk. But, as I started writing about the photo, I came to realize that there was enough to say about it that I should save it for a blog-post.

I already have tomorrow’s blog-post written (and I promised someone–two days ago–I’d post that in one or two days), so look for my blog-post about the photo to appear on the day after tomorrow.

]]> By: Cherrona http://ruleofrosemysteries.com/2008/10/27/clues/i-always-watch-you-from-the-sky-wrote-wendy/#comment-7883 Cherrona Tue, 28 Oct 2008 08:35:31 +0000 http://ruleofrosemysteries.com/?p=234#comment-7883 I can't really remember, but is there anywhere in the game that definitively proves Gregory had a son to begin with? I know in the letter from the police to Martha it said something about him being seen with a boy of similar description to his son (or something along those lines) but maybe he has always been unstable and there never was a real Joshua. Just different children dressed as him. But then again I can't really remember much about the files found, and I'm sort of just rambling. lol I can’t really remember, but is there anywhere in the game that definitively proves Gregory had a son to begin with? I know in the letter from the police to Martha it said something about him being seen with a boy of similar description to his son (or something along those lines) but maybe he has always been unstable and there never was a real Joshua. Just different children dressed as him.
But then again I can’t really remember much about the files found, and I’m sort of just rambling. lol

]]> By: fireflys_locket http://ruleofrosemysteries.com/2008/10/27/clues/i-always-watch-you-from-the-sky-wrote-wendy/#comment-7882 fireflys_locket Tue, 28 Oct 2008 08:22:58 +0000 http://ruleofrosemysteries.com/?p=234#comment-7882 <blockquote>But if Wendy has to come from the orphanage to Gregory’s house to watch Jennifer, can Wendy still say “I always watch you from the sky” and have “from the sky” mean from the airship?</blockquote> That's a good point. It might just be that she pretends that the window is a window in the airship, even when no other part of the Gingerbread House is. Or maybe when she says watches... it means more like she's just thinking about her from afar. Looking out the window and not actually seeing her, but maybe seeing the house and knowing she's in there. This makes me wonder, though... is the Rose Garden considered a part of the airship? If not, then when an orphan (mostly Wendy) leaves the orphanage grounds, is it like the airship has landed? That probably seems like a silly question, though. I guess it depends on just how deeply the imaginary world was a part of them. Was it still it in their mind if they left? Or were they just not playing at that moment? Maybe I'm thinking too much. Apologies. ^_^

But if Wendy has to come from the orphanage to Gregory’s house to watch Jennifer, can Wendy still say “I always watch you from the sky” and have “from the sky” mean from the airship?

That’s a good point. It might just be that she pretends that the window is a window in the airship, even when no other part of the Gingerbread House is. Or maybe when she says watches… it means more like she’s just thinking about her from afar. Looking out the window and not actually seeing her, but maybe seeing the house and knowing she’s in there.

This makes me wonder, though… is the Rose Garden considered a part of the airship? If not, then when an orphan (mostly Wendy) leaves the orphanage grounds, is it like the airship has landed? That probably seems like a silly question, though. I guess it depends on just how deeply the imaginary world was a part of them. Was it still it in their mind if they left? Or were they just not playing at that moment?

Maybe I’m thinking too much. Apologies. ^_^

]]>